Skip to content

Do Products Make Your Hair Curly? Why Some Curls Only Show Up With Gel

No. Products can’t make straight hair curly. Whether hair grows straight, wavy or curly is set by the shape of the hair follicle. What products can do is show curls that are already there: fine curls are often pulled straight by their own weight, frizz breaks up curl clumps, and brushing separates them. A gel or mousse holds the curls in shape while they dry, so hair that looked “straight-ish” can turn out to be wavy or curly.

This argument blew up online this month. An X post saying your hair isn’t naturally curly if you need three different products, a special brush and a diffuser to get curls got more than 7,500 likes. On Reddit, a post calling the curly girl method a lie designed to sell products drew 172 comments, and another person’s post asked if anyone else hadn’t known their hair was curly because it was always short and straight.

What decides whether hair is curly

Hair shape starts under the skin. A 2017 review in Experimental Dermatology (Westgate, Ginger and Green) sums up the research: a curved, asymmetric follicle produces a curly hair, and a straight follicle produces a straight one. The follicle’s shape is set by genetics. No shampoo, gel or brush changes it.

One X user replying to the debate put it simply: “if your hair is not curly, no amount of product can give you curls.”

Why some curls only show up with products

If your follicles make a curve, the hair has a curl pattern. But plenty of things hide it:

  • Weight. Fine, long hair is pulled down by its own weight, so the curl at the top stretches out. Another X user said their hair is “straight when wet but forms loose ringlets as it dries”, and that it’s “not pattern, it’s texture”: superfine hair behaves differently from coarser hair.
  • Heavy products. Rich creams and oils can weigh fine curls down further. One X user said their hair looks straight “bc it’s so fine it gets weighed down but it’s technically curly”, and only shows its pattern with light products.
  • Brushing dry. Brushing splits curl clumps into separate strands, which looks like frizz. On Reddit’s wavy hair forum, a newcomer whose hair looked frizzy was told to stop brushing it dry and that “This isn’t a moisture issue”: the hair needed a styling product to keep the curls together.
  • Short hair. Many people never see their curls because they’ve always worn their hair short.
  • Water and humidity. Water temporarily breaks some of the bonds that hold a hair’s shape, which is why curls reform as hair dries. In humid weather, curls can swell into frizz instead.

So the debate on X is partly about two different things. Products don’t create curls. But for fine, wavy or loosely curly hair, the right products can be the difference between seeing the curl pattern and not seeing it.

Do you need products at all?

Not necessarily. On Reddit’s curly hair forum, one poster shared photos of their hair with and without styling products, and said they prefer it without, because it gives their thin hair more volume. The post got more than 650 upvotes. A Reddit user replied: “If your hair looks the way you like without product, don’t use product.”

Others said it’s a trade-off. “Having to choose between volume and definition is frustrating,” one wrote. Another, with very fine but dense hair, said they use gel only, because it gives definition and makes curls last without weighing their hair down.

If you want to try less:

  1. Shampoo and condition only, and finger-comb in the shower. See how your hair dries untouched.
  2. Add one light product, such as a mousse or a light gel, on soaking-wet hair.
  3. Skip heavy creams and oils at the roots if your hair is fine.
  4. Don’t brush once it’s dry.

Is the curly girl method a scam?

It’s a routine, not a product. The curly girl method is a set of habits: gentle cleansing, conditioning, styling on wet hair and not brushing dry. It doesn’t require any particular brand, and you can follow it with a few cheap products. Where people get frustrated is the long product lists online. Our curly girl method beginners’ guide covers the basics without them.

In the UAE

The viral X thread started from a post in Arabic by someone explaining what they mean when they say their hair is soft but curly, a description many people with fine curls will recognise. Fine curls are the ones most easily hidden by weight and heavy products. In dry, air-conditioned air they can also frizz rather than clump. A light leave-in and a light gel on wet hair are a good first test. If your curls only show when wet, read why hair is curly when wet but dries straight, and for a full routine see our fine curly hair routine.

Quick answers

Can products make straight hair curly? No. Hair shape is set by the shape of the follicle. Products can only show and hold curls you already have.

Why is my hair only curly with gel? Gel holds curls in shape while they dry. Without it, fine curls may be pulled straight by their own weight or broken up into frizz.

Is my hair really curly if I need products? If your hair forms waves or curls when it’s left to dry untouched, it has a curl pattern, whether or not you use products to define it.

Do I need the curly girl method? No. It’s one set of habits that works for many people. Use as much or as little of it as your hair needs.

Author