Skip to content

Do Shower Filters Work for Hard Water? What Actually Helps Curly Hair

Most shower filters don’t soften hard water. A typical showerhead filter is designed to reduce chlorine, not the calcium and magnesium that make water hard. If hard water is the problem, the options that work on the minerals themselves are a water softener (a whole-home unit or a portable shower softener) or a chelating shampoo that removes mineral build-up from your hair.

This came up in five threads on Reddit’s curly hair forums this month, with about 15 people discussing filters and softeners. Two people in different threads gave the same short answer. One said: “A showerhead filter can only filter out the chlorine, it can’t soften the water.” Another: “Shower head filters cannot reduce water hardness.”

What a shower filter is tested for

The only American national standard for shower filters, NSF/ANSI 177 (Shower Filtration Systems: Aesthetic Effects), covers one performance claim: reducing free available chlorine, the disinfectant added to tap water. A filter certified to it has been tested for how much chlorine it removes, plus material safety and durability. The standard doesn’t cover calcium or magnesium.

So a certified filter can make a real difference if your shower water smells of chlorine. It won’t do much about the white marks on your taps.

What Reddit users found

People who’d bought a filter for their curls mostly said it didn’t fix the problem:

  • One Reddit user said they have a water filter on their shower “but I don’t think it actually softens it”.
  • Another put a filter on their shower head, and it “didn’t fix this aspect” of their dry, brittle next-day hair.
  • A poster with second-day curl problems said they use a shower filter because they couldn’t find another way to deal with hard water that didn’t cost thousands.

Not everyone agreed. One Reddit user said a shower head filter “helps a lot”, and another said their curls were “amazing and perfect” at a friend’s place that had a water-softening shower head. That second one is a softener, not a filter, which is the point: the device has to remove minerals.

What actually deals with hard water

1. A water softener. Softeners remove the minerals, usually by ion exchange. Several Reddit users said they bought a portable softener that fits between the pipe and the shower head, and one recharges theirs about once a month for a two-person household. Another said to compare the resin capacity before buying, because some need recharging much more often than others in very hard water. Renters can ask their landlord whether the building already has one.

2. A chelating shampoo. A clarifying shampoo removes product build-up. A chelating shampoo goes further and binds to minerals so they rinse away. Look for chelating agents such as EDTA (often listed as disodium or tetrasodium EDTA), phytic acid or sodium gluconate on the label, or a “hard water” or “chelating” claim. Reddit users named L’Oréal’s chelating shampoo and Malibu C packets; we don’t stock either. One Reddit user called Malibu C “so strong” and said it can be very drying, so follow a chelating wash with a rich conditioner or mask. See how often to clarify and our deep conditioning masks post.

3. A final rinse. One Reddit user said rinsing with distilled water has helped a lot of people, though it’s a hassle to do every time.

Is hard water actually bad for curly hair?

The research is mixed. A 2013 study in the International Journal of Trichology found no difference in strength or elasticity between hair soaked in hard water and in distilled water. A 2016 study in the Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association and a 2018 follow-up in the International Journal of Trichology found hair treated with very hard water was weaker, about 8% lower tensile strength in the 2018 study. The 2016 study’s authors point out that their water was more than twice as hard as the water in the 2013 study.

What curly-haired people describe most often isn’t breakage but build-up: dull, stiff, straw-like curls that don’t respond to products. Our hard water guide covers the signs and fixes in more detail.

Check your water first

Before buying anything, find out what you’re dealing with. Two Reddit users suggested cheap hard water test strips. One pointed out that moving house is when many people notice hard water, and they often blame stress or their products instead. Another said stress after a move can also change your hair, so test the water rather than guessing.

In the UAE

Water can differ from one building to the next, so a neighbour’s experience may not match yours. Signs of hard water at home are white, chalky marks on taps, glass and shower screens, and soap that won’t lather well. If you see them and your curls feel coated, try a chelating shampoo every few washes before spending on hardware. If your water smells of chlorine, a filter certified to NSF/ANSI 177 is the right tool for that. If you have both, you may need a softener and a filter, or a unit that does both.

Quick answers

Do shower filters soften water? Most don’t. Standard showerhead filters are made and tested to reduce chlorine, not the calcium and magnesium in hard water.

What does soften shower water? A water softener, usually one that uses ion exchange. Portable versions fit between the pipe and the shower head and need recharging.

Is a chelating shampoo the same as a clarifying shampoo? No. Clarifying shampoos remove product build-up; chelating shampoos also bind to minerals from hard water. Some products do both.

Will a shower filter help my curls? If chlorine is drying your hair, maybe. If hard water is the problem, a softener or chelating shampoo is more likely to help.

Author